Staff Picks

Miguel's Top Picks	Norman's Top Picks	Johnny's Top Picks
Cream Machine by Caldwell What I love about this one is how the flavors evolve as you smoke it. You get hints of vanilla and a bit of nuttiness, which makes it interesting without being too complex. It’s a great choice for beginners and those who appreciate mild to medium smoke that’s easy on the palate.	Stolen Throne Crook of The Crown This cigar by far was the cigar I chased the most when it was first released 5 years ago. I remember the first time I smoked it, I frantically went online trying to find more and searched and searched for 6 months till it finally came back in stock. This is an every day smoke for me.	La Galera 1936 Box Press This cigar is a constant favorite of mine. I find myself reaching for it throughout the day, whether it’s with morning coffee, a refreshing seltzer, or a nice bourbon. Its complex notes of dried fruit, baking spices, and earthy undertones, with hints of caramel and cinnamon, keep me coming back for more. It never disappoints, making it one of my top choices that I’ll never turn down.
10th Anniversary by Rojas	Casdagli Traditional Cottontail	Casdagli Traditional Cottontail
The construction of this cigar is impeccable. It burns evenly and produces a nice, smooth draw every time. The balance of flavors makes it a great choice for both beginners and more seasoned smokers looking for something with a bit of depth without being too strong. Every time I light up a 10th Anniversary, it feels like a special occasion. It's perfect when you want to treat yourself to something a little extra without going overboard. This cigar has definitely earned its place as a staff favorite here at The Cigar Vault, and I highly recommend giving it a try.	I remember someone once told me that Casdagli should be consider the Davidoff throughout Europe. The more I have enjoyed this stick the more complex the flavors have built up. This smoke at first might not be a shape or size you are familiar with but its a banger that is enjoyable. This is a much longer smoke than it looks given the larger gauge at the front of the cigar	They call me Johnny Cottontail.
Vault Reserva Habano Behike	Powstanie Justice	Tattoo by Tatuaje
What stands out to me about this cigar is its bold flavor profile. It starts with a robust earthiness and then unfolds into layers of spice, leather, and a hint of sweetness. Each puff is like discovering a new facet of its character, making it a truly enjoyable experience from start to finish.	It was hard for me to figure out which Powstanie stick to put in my list because I really enjoy the entire line that Mike creates. I went with the justice just because if I looked at my top 6 and I felt it brought balance. Even though this is a Connecticut wrapper, the PA Broadleaf under it gives this stick some kick. Its fantastic.	This cigar brings me joy at any time of day. Its blend of wood, baking spices, and earthy flavors is incredibly enjoyable, complemented by leather and pepper undertones that put a smile on my face. The price is a bonus—how can something this good be so affordable? I just savor the experience without questioning it.
Plum Pudding by Seattle Pipe Club	Tatuaje Loki	Just the Tip by Caldwell Lost & Found
What makes Plum Pudding special is its robust blend of Latakia, Orientals, Virginias, and Perique tobaccos. It delivers a smoky, spicy, and slightly sweet profile that evolves as you smoke. The Latakia provides a smoky backbone, while the Orientals add spice and the Virginias contribute sweetness. The Perique adds a touch of peppery zest that completes the blend. The blend is well-balanced, allowing each component to shine without overpowering the others. It burns cool and smooth, providing a relaxing and contemplative smoking experience.	As a person that smokes a ton of tatuaje, I wanted to make this about a core line product product instead of the monster series. This stick to me is probably one of my all time favorite Tatuajue that are produced and is created out of Miami. Its just a completely balanced stick that has pepper but the dark cocoa that comes out is always front and center. Its just a great cigar and never disappoints.	I can’t get enough of retrohaling this cigar! The rich flavors are addictive, and I appreciate its uniqueness. The combination of creamy leather, nuts, and chocolate is delightful. For the price, it’s a fantastic choice that you can’t go wrong with.
Leather Rose by Deadwood	Caldwell Long Live the Queen	Lil' Tony by Lure
What stands out about the Leather Rose is its blend of flavors that include hints of cocoa, coffee, and a subtle sweetness. These elements come together to create a rich and satisfying smoke that's both enjoyable and memorable. This is a cigar I turn to when I want to indulge in something that’s both flavorful and aromatic.	Following back up on a nice late morning smoke this would be one I tend to reach for. It burns fairly slow and is subtle but full of depth. It is an extremely smooth cigar where you can get a creamy smoothness, with secondary hints of coffee bean. Again, first stick of the day you would not be disappointed.	This cigar delivers an abundance of leather, and I love it! Whether you call it bootlicker, leather ball gag, or creamy leather baseball mitt, it all fits. With notes of baking spices, dried fruit, and espresso, it shares a common thread with my top five cigars. Don’t overlook this little gem!
West Tampa Red by West Tampa	Traficante Brooklyn	Vault Reserva Maduro CB
What I enjoy most about the West Tampa Red is its rich, earthy tones complemented by hints of spice and a subtle sweetness. It’s the kind of cigar that evokes a sense of nostalgia while still delivering a satisfying smoke that’s enjoyable in any setting.	Rounding off my selection is a bomb that Traficante. Even before you light the cigar you will get cocoa when smell it. Its is full of pepper and dark chocolate. Its a strong stick and definitely one to close out the night or late afternoon. Smoke it slow to not burn the final 3rd	What can I say? CB stands for "chocolate bomb," and this cigar truly delivers. Rich cocoa and espresso notes create an unforgettable sweetness. Despite its 6 x 60 size, it smokes like a robusto or toro, and once you light it up, you’ll forget the size as you indulge in its sweet, chocolaty delight. Just a warning: it’s incredibly addictive—and it’s not infused!